We should maintain that if an interpretation of any word in any religion leads to disharmony and does not positively further the welfare of the many, then such an interpretation is to be regarded as wrong; that is, against the will of God, or as the working of Satan or Mara.

Buddhadasa Bikkhu, a Thai Buddhist Monk


Monday, February 25, 2013

Weight Loss as Cultural Change

One key reason that it is so difficult to lose weight permanently is that it requires the losers of weight to go through a change of their eating preferences, habits, attitudes, and values, all of which taken together amounts to a significant change in a key part of their culture.  Those of us who have lived for significant periods of time in another culture understand that personal cultural change is not easy even when we are living in another culture where all of the cues around us encourage and sustain that change.  Trying to change our eating culture in the midst of the culture of obesity that we encounter every day is considerably more difficult.  Our culture encourages us to eat the way we always did, the way that massively encourages us to put on the pounds we want to shed.

It is not "natural" for us to moderate our eating habits.  It is not "natural" to avoid refined sugar and refrain from consuming it.  It is not "natural" to eat things like pine nuts and drink things like green tea while not eating quantities of  "natural things" like breads, cheeses, and pizzas.  We grew up with soft drinks.  Most of us didn't drink tea until we were adults, if we do now.  What makes it so difficult to change is that all around us society goes on consuming what we should not consume and encouraging us to do so in many different ways from advertising to coffee hour at church.

Medical science may yet come up with a way for us to lose weight without giving up our culturally driven bad eating habits—probably will.  But, until that time comes, we best be working on changing our eating culture collectively.  We need the same cultural changes in attitudes and behaviors that have transformed smoking from desired to disgusting.  Amen.

Saturday, February 23, 2013

Sounds of the Universe

The 11 minute video clip below, "Honor Harger: A history of the universe in sound," is a fascinating introduction into the sounds of the universe.  Honor Hager, originally from New Zealand, is the Artistic Director Lighthouse, "a digital culture agency" based in Brighton, England, that supports, commissions and exhibits work by artists and filmmakers.  If you do meditations and/or prayers of any sort, this clip is worthy of inclusion.  Be sure and stay to the end, which is the best moment of all.  Enjoy!

Friday, February 22, 2013

Two Presbyterian Roads

In a recent posting entitled, "An essential Presbyterian conflict: Reformed versus Celtic faith," the Rev. N. Graham Standish argues that one facet of the conflict among Presbyterians today is our dual heritage of a dualistic Reformed-Augustinian theological tradition and a more holistic Celtic spiritual tradition. He writes, "Certainly there are other ways of analyzing the conflicts we have in the PC(USA), but looking at these roots is one way. And if this analysis is true, then we may be in conflict because our Reformed side regards human nature as essentially tainted, while our Celtic side regards human nature as essentially good." He goes on to flesh out the difference between these two traditions: "The more Reformed we are, the more we tend to gravitate towards an Augustinian, fall theology, interpreting Bible through the story of Genesis 3. We embrace the idea that original sin has tainted all of humankind, leaving us depraved and requiring God’s grace to forgive and redeem us...The more Celtic we are, the more we interpret the Bible through Genesis 1, gravitating towards a “goodness” theology grounded in God’s declaration that all in creation are “good. This theology recognizes the power of sin, and the need for grace. But it is tempered by a belief that our natural inclinations are good, and become sinful when gratifying these inclinations turns them into false gods to be appeased. Grace restores us to our natural, essential goodness."

The website, Celtic Christianity Today, contains a page on "Celtic Theological Attitudes," which provides a good orientation to the Celtic tradition.  For a longer description of Celtic spirituality see (here).

The extent to which PC(USA) and other American Presbyterian denominations are heirs to Celtic spiritual traditions is not clear to me.  A brief article by J. Philip Newell with the title, "Celtic spirituality listens for the heartbeat of God: Presbyterianism is influenced by ancient Celtic and Mediterranean traditions," actually seems to indicate that we have not been influenced by that tradition but should be.  It seems more likely that the un-evangelical wing of PC(USA) might become more interested in Celtic spirituality because that spirituality more nearly expresses the temper of our times, which as is becoming less and less dualistic, than because it is a part of our Scottish Presbyterian heritage.  In any event, Standish does touch on a central difference and source of conflict between Presbyterians today.  On the one hand, those who are leaving the denomination in increasing numbers tend to begin with a generally clear dualistic theology and work toward a consistent spirituality.  On the other hand, at least some of those who are staying tend to begin with a less dualistic spirituality and work toward a more inclusive theology.

Thursday, February 21, 2013

Christian Non-self

Yesterday, I shared with you the thought that the Apostle Paul in Galatians 2:15-21 didn't go far enough in working out his profound spiritual insight that we are not reconciled with God by keeping the Law.  He was still seeking a legal state, justification, but proposes a non-legal remedy, faith.  The problem is that faith can too easily be turned back into a work of the Law because at some level we have to do something to be justified.  We have to believe, which is too often taken as the same thing as faith.

The concern for justification, thus, can obscure the most important consequence of Paul's insight, namely "For through the law I died to the law, so that I might live to God. I have been crucified with Christ; and it is no longer I who live, but it is Christ who lives in me. And the life I now live in the flesh I live by faith in the Son of God, who loved me and gave himself for me." (2:19-20, NRSV, italics added)  If we live in faith, it is no longer "us" who lives at all but Christ who lives in us.  This does not seem to be a kind of self-nullification, however.  It is self-fulfillment, which when achieved merges "us" with the One who created us.  In an almost Buddhist way, "we" become a non-self and the "space" formerly occupied by our unfaithful "self" is now occupied by that One, by Christ.

In our walk of faith, we discover that I Alone is empty of meaning and purpose, that I Together is better but still filled with hurt, and that Not I But Thee is the surest way to a life of meaning and purpose.  As Paul says, "It is no longer I who live, but it is Christ who lives in me."  For all but a few, that is a goal and a possibility more than a reality, but it is the goal or a path on which we  seek to walk in faith.  Amen

Wednesday, February 20, 2013

Getting Beyond the Law

It was the Apostle Paul's amazing spiritual insight that humanity cannot be justified in the eyes of God by keeping the Jewish Law.  As Christians, we are justified by our faith in Christ.  This is the point he makes in Galatians 5:15-21, which has become settled Christian theology and ethics.  In all of the standard English-language versions (for example), the same language is used to make Paul's point: humanity is not justified by works of the law but by faith (2:15-16).  The Message and Today's English Version translate "justified" (see here) as either being put right or set right with God, which seems slightly different but not that much so.  All of these translations retain Paul's legal terminology of justification, being proven not guilty in a court of law.  Yes, "justification" can mean more than that (see here), but its legal sense lingers in the other possible meanings.

The problem here is that if we are justified by faith rather than the law, we are still being justified.  We are still operating in a legal framework.  Our understanding of how faith operates in our personal faith is still tinged (tainted, if you will) by the idea that we need to be justified in the eyes of God.  And while it was surely neither his experience or intent, Paul's insight that we are justified by faith too often fails to free the faithful from the Law.  Indeed, it can turn faith into a form of law.  Faith becomes something we have to achieve in order to be justified.  Yes, yes, it is not supposed to be that way, but generations of faithful believers have and many still do worry about whether or not they have been "put right" with God.  Is their faith genuine?  How do they know?  The surest indication that faith has been sucked into the legal realm is how closely it is tied to judgment and judgmental attitudes.  There has long been a huge cottage industry among Christians aimed at judging who is "really" a faithful follower of Christ and who is not according to one measure or another of what is "real faith."  And that is a legal concern.

Interestingly, the Laughing Bird paraphrase of Galatians 2:15-16 manages to remove the matter of faith and works from the legal realm.  It has these two verses saying, "We ourselves are not lawless Gentiles, but 'born and bred Jews'—people of the law.  However, we now know that this gives us no particular advantage, because God's approval is not a reward for careful compliance with the law, but a gift to those who entrust themselves to Jesus Christ."  Here, the issue at stake is the gift of God's approval and the route to that approval is faith.  We are not longer standing in a court of law before God the stern Judge but in the kitchen with God the loving Mother.

Paul gives us the freedom to no longer hold to the legal metaphor for understanding our relationship with God and to discover other metaphors for that relationship instead, such as one centered on our experience of family.  Historically, I assume that Paul did mean for us to stick with the legal metaphor but it also seems to me that his insight that justification is by faith freed him from the Law and by implication allows us to be freed from the legal metaphor—to see our relationship with God is a fundamentally different way, one that is not at all outside of the biblical tradition.  God is "Abba" (Mark 14:36) not Judge.  Faith really is a matter of trust in God, not of measuring up to God's expectations.

Tuesday, February 19, 2013

Listen

Listen to your life.

Frederick Buechner
Listening to Your Life (HarperOne, 1992), p. 2

Monday, February 18, 2013

On the Horns of a Dilemma

In a world that is increasingly inclusive, it is difficult to maintain the integrity of an exclusivist Christian faith.  The problem is this: those who hold to an exclusive gospel—that is that only Christ saves—often care deeply about those who do not share their faith.  They are convinced that "non-believers" are going to hell.  They want to communicate with non-believers about their plight and help them escape it.  Communication is important.  However, in a world that  increasingly rejects exclusive ideologies, it is all but impossible for exclusivists to communicate across the boundaries of their exclusive message.  Fewer and fewer people find any kind of exclusivism to be "good news."

This is a real dilemma.  A recent example of it has engulfed the Lutheran Church—Missouri Synod in controversy over the participation of one of its pastors in ecumenical services held at the time of the Sandy Hook tragedy in Newtown, CT.  As widely reported (here), the pastor of Newtown's Christ the King Lutheran Church was reprimanded by the president of the Missouri Synod church, for taking part in an ecumenical service in Newtown in spite of the fact that one of the children murdered at Sandy Hook Elementary was a child of Christ the King Church.  The pastor did apologize for upsetting the denomination although not for his action.  Now, the president in his turn has felt compelled to apologize to the denomination for his own actions (here).  His letter of apology can be found on the Missouri Synod website (here).

The president's letter articulates the dilemma he and his denomination face in their exclusivist approach to the Christian faith.  In the letter, he states,
As the nation struggles with increasing violence and tragedy, we as a church body have struggled and continue to struggle with how to respond to civic/religious services in the midst of such events and to do so in a way that is in accord with our core convictions about the uniqueness of Christ. There are strong differences of opinion on this issue within the Missouri Synod, and that is because we all take our commitments to the Bible and to serving the neighbor very seriously. One view is that by standing side-by-side with non-Christian clergy in public religious events, we give the impression that Christ is just one path among many. Others view participation as an opportunity to share Christ and to truly love a hurting community, which may not happen if we are not participating. We struggle with the tension between these two views. We all deeply want to support our hurting communities in ways consistent with our religious convictions. (italics added)
That's the dilemma: engaging with those in need while remaining disengaged from those who believe the wrong things when those in need and those who don't believe are one and the same.  So, sitting on a stage with other clergy is wrong, but sitting with clergy ministering to a community in deep pain is not.  For a consistent exclusivist, sitting with the other clergy is always wrong and cannot be done, which seems to have been the initial position of the Missouri Synod president.  In an increasingly pluralistic, inclusive age, his reprimand of the pastor is widely seen as hurtful—among Missouri Synod members as well as in the public.

In sum, in an increasingly inclusive and pluralistic American culture exclusivist versions of the gospel are increasingly seen as bad news.  Exclusivism builds walls, encourages judgmentalism, and forces its adherents to behave in ways that others find unloving.  And often enough it is its own "reward," as can be seen in the case of the controversy sparked by Missouri Synod narrowness in the face of the Newtown tragedy.

Saturday, February 16, 2013

"Something" Really Seems to be Happening

A Couple of weeks ago, I posted an entry here that posed the question, "Is "Something" Happening?"  It played with the idea that certain trends in social attitudes and behavior suggest that there is a fundamental transformation quietly taking place in the world.  One of the clearest shifts in this family of social changes is our rapidly changing attitudes in the U.S. towards the gay community—which reflects ongoing changes in attitudes regarding race and gender.

Add to these changes yet another one, which was recently reported on in an article posted on the Christian Science Monitor website (here).  The article draws on statistics from the Bureau of Justice (here), which show that, quoting the DOJ, "From 1994 to 2010, the overall rate of intimate partner violence in the United States declined by 64%."  The article attributes this significant drop in domestic violence to "a broad shift in attitude toward domestic violence."

It is hard to measure in real terms what this drop in partner abuse means because it describes an absence of evil.  It points to  lives not destroyed and families not maimed by violence.  This statistic is about sad, hurtful stories that can't be told because they never happened, apparently tens and hundreds of thousands of such stories, if not millions.  While it is true that the absence of violence is not peace, reducing domestic violence in such a large measure is surely a step in the right direction.

This doesn't mean that all of sudden everything is sweetness & light, but still I'm tellin' ya, there is "something" going on in our world today—a very good "something".

Friday, February 15, 2013

The Danger of Dualism

For an illuminating, succinct commentary on the consequences of religious and political  dualistic thinking, check out the following brief video.  Enjoy!


Thursday, February 14, 2013

Reality, Truth, & Scripture

Jacob Set Up a Pillar at Rachel's Grave (Gen. 35:20)
 Genesis 35:16-21 comes after the famous story of Jacob's dream of a ladder between heaven and earth and recounts the birth of Jacob's son, Benjamin, and the death of his wife Rachael.  The passage concludes in verse 21 with the statement that, "Israel [Jacob] journeyed on, and pitched his tent beyond the tower of Eder." (NRSV)   Of this verse and passage, Walter Brueggemann observes, "As though to stress the historical reality of this family, that it must face death and move on, the narrator ends with the brief report, 'Israel journeyed on...'" (Brueggemann, Genesis, 284).  As I understand it, Brueggemann himself is not claiming that there was a "historical Jacob" but that the narrator believed that to be the case and was highlighting that assumption with the words, "Israel journeyed on..."

The Wikipedia article on "Jacob" states, "Most biblical scholars and historians of ancient Israel today view the patriarchical narratives, including the life of Jacob, as late (6th and 5th centuries BCE) literary compositions that have ideological and theological purposes but are unreliable for historical reconstruction of the presettlement period of Israel’s past."

The average reader and some professional historians might conclude, thus, that the Genesis stories about Jacob (and more generally) are "not true" and have no historical value.  That is a wrong conclusion.  In a very important sense, whether or not there was a "historical Jacob," is neither here nor there.  The story is historically accurate and even factual—in the sense that it accurately reflects the real religious experience of ancient Israel and truly reflects the nature of the life of faith in a given historical period.  Now, that  period may not be the "presettlement period" before the Hebrews took possession of Palestine.  It may well be that it reflects the time of the Exile and post-exilic era, the time when scholars think these stories were stitched together into the Book of Genesis.  Nonetheless, the book of Genesis is a reliable document in the historical reconstruction of ancient Israel's life and faith.

Historians ask two kinds of factual questions.  First and more precisely, did the events recounted actually happen?  Second and more broadly, what does the account tell them about the past?  In this case, the historian has every reason to doubt whether the events recorded in Genesis actually too place.  Many of them seem improbable, and there is no corroborating evidence.  What the historian can safely assume, however, is that the form and content of the Book of Genesis story do reflect the real world of ancient Israel.  In this more general sense, Genesis is historical and a valuable historical document.

As scripture, then, we have confidence in the story of Jacob in at least two ways.  First, we know that it accurately reflects a moment in our faith tradition that remains important to us today because of its influence on the course of our history and because of what we can learn about our faith from it.  Second, scripture for us is inspired, that is the Spirit speaks through it to us.  For most Christians, it is important that the voice of the Spirit be grounded in historical reality.  Ours is an incarnational faith.  We know from the study of the past (history) that this portion of scripture is grounded in historical realities.  In faith, we trust in the spiritual fact that the Spirit thus speaks through these stories across the span of generations to us.