We should maintain that if an interpretation of any word in any religion leads to disharmony and does not positively further the welfare of the many, then such an interpretation is to be regarded as wrong; that is, against the will of God, or as the working of Satan or Mara.

Buddhadasa Bikkhu, a Thai Buddhist Monk


Showing posts with label United Church of Christ. Show all posts
Showing posts with label United Church of Christ. Show all posts

Wednesday, July 13, 2011

Speaking of God

In the course of amending its constitution, the United Church of Christ (UCC) has recently changed a reference to God in the constitution from "God as heavenly Father," to "the triune God."  The draft of this change as shown in the on line version of the amended text, which you can find here (see lines 82-83), unfortunately shows the words God "as heavenly Father" highlighted in red with a glaring strike through.  Certain more conservative UCC groups jumped on the change as being a rejection of God the Father.  One website announced the impending wording change with the blaring headline, "UNITED CHURCH OF CHRIST SET TO REJECT GOD THE FATHER."  A few other non-UCC websites picked up the story, one with its own sensationalist headline that reads, "'God the Father' banished by mainline denomination."

Putting aside the critics for a moment, the change in the UCC constitution raises an important theological issue that mainline churches have been wrestling with for some fifty years.  How do we speak about the First Person of the Trinity?  Traditionally, of course, "he" is God the "Father."  In the wake of the feminist movement and the continuing almost tectonic shift in the place of women in American society, however, it has become more problematic to continue to chain the First Person of the Trinity to human male images.  There is a justice issue here as well as a fundamental issue concerning how we image God.  It can be argued that imaging the First Person as male is or borders on being idolatrous, that is treating God as if "he" was created in the image of a human male.  The biblical doctrine is, of course, that all of us male and female are images of God and not God images of half of us, the traditionally socially dominant half at that.

Now, we can come down on different sides of the question of how we image and speak of the First Person of the Trinity especially because referring to "the [genderless] First Person of the Trinity" is rather awkward.  The image of God as father, furthermore, captures important facts about God and has biblical precedence.  At the same time, imaging The First Person as either gender traps us into actually thinking of God as a person in the way we are persons.  Indeed, even using the word "person" in English to describe the three aspects or faces of God is itself problematic.  My point is that the UCC has good reason to change its constitutional reference to God, and those who disagree have good reasons for opposing the change.  We could do without the demonizing rhetoric, that's all.

Thursday, June 30, 2011

Rep. Akin Follow-up

Under the posting title, "These Are Sad Times," this past Tuesday I shared with readers the comment made by Rep. Todd Akin (R - MO) that liberals at heart are God-haters who want to replace God with big government.  He made the comment last Friday.  Monday, he refused to apologize for it, but then on Tuesday he made one of those non-apology apologies that essentially means he still believes liberalism breeds God-hating (source).

Today,  three United Church of Christ clergy leaders plus a Unitarian Universalist cleric plan to deliver a letter of protest to Rep. Akin.  The text of the letter reads,
"As Missourians of faith, we found your statement that "at the heart of liberalism really is a hatred of God and a belief that government should replace God" to be ignorant and offensive. Scripture clearly warns us to "judge not, lest ye be judged," yet you condemn in disrespectful, stereotypical terms those with whom you disagree. Such insulting pronouncements degrade our nation's political dialogue and are unworthy of a public servant who claims to represent the interests of all of his constituents.
"And in light of your support for a federal budget that mainstream faith leaders have overwhelmingly condemned as punitive toward the poorest among us, we call on you to reconsider not only your words, but also your moral priorities as a political leader. Accusing others of being inspired by hatred of God while you vote to deprive the weakest and most vulnerable of medicine and basic sustenance is the antithesis of moral leadership. We call on you to apologize, and we pray that you are moved to act in a spirit of civility, compassion and justice in the future." (source)
Talk about ships passing in the night.  This is a classic example.  Given the judgmental tone of the clergy response, the bit about not judging so you won't get judged probably could have been best dropped.  And while the statement about Akin's voting record may be as the letter describes it, Akin could argue that his votes are not against the poor but for fiscal responsibility, which is also a moral issue.  The letter's moral indignation at his voting record echoes Akin's moral indignation at liberalism, although it is targeted much more narrowly and doesn't make blanket statements about conservatives.  Still, it is an expression of liberal indignation hitting back at Akin's conservative indignation at NBC's removal of "under God" from the pledge of allegiance.

Both Akin and the clergy are committed Christians. who seem to be better at preaching than listening, which is a weakness we all share no matter what our political ideology or theology.  We do not seem to be able to temper our ideologies and theologies for the sake of mutual forbearance and reconciliation—for the sake of the Gospel.  If well-intentioned followers of Christ cannot find ways past their politics, how can we expect others to do so?  These are indeed sad times.