We should maintain that if an interpretation of any word in any religion leads to disharmony and does not positively further the welfare of the many, then such an interpretation is to be regarded as wrong; that is, against the will of God, or as the working of Satan or Mara.

Buddhadasa Bikkhu, a Thai Buddhist Monk


Showing posts with label Todd Akin. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Todd Akin. Show all posts

Thursday, August 23, 2012

Todd Is At It Again

RPK's "old friend," Rep. Todd Akin (R - MO) is at it again.  Just a year ago, he stirred up controversy over his assertion that liberals hate God and want to replace God with big government (see here).  Although Akin gave a half-hearted apology, he refused to meet with liberal clergy from his own district and successfully waited the whole thing out.  In fact, we can suspect that his stand against the liberals actually gave him further credit with his own base and didn't hurt in the least in his successful bid to become the GOP candidate for the U. S. Senate in this year's election.

Akin is at it again, as most readers know.  His use of the term "legitimate rape" and stated belief that women who are "legitimately raped" seldom become pregnant has set off a fire storm, primarily on the left but even from members of his own party.  There were widespread calls from within the Republican Party for his resignation, while Democrats have been keeping their fingers crossed in hopes that he would refuse.  And Akin has.  He issued an apology, and has avowed that he intends to fight on.  We can assume that he thinks that he can wait this one out too.  The dust will settle.  The media will go on to something else.  MSNBC commentators will find something else to rant about.  And he can resume his potent challenge for the senate seat in Missouri.

Let's face it.  He may be right.  But, somethings are different his time.  In the short run, he has given the Democrats an opportunity to force Romney off message yet again.  Every day, every week that they can divert him from his attacks on President Obama's fiscal record is a good day, a good week for the Democrats.  He has also managed to reignite the "Republicans are anti-women" theme, which seemed to have gone quiet. And he has drawn attention to the Republican Party's radical anti-abortion stance, which seeks to criminalize abortions for virtually every case—including rape and incest.  Vice Presidential candidate, Paul Ryan, is among those suddenly thrown on the defensive.  This is not, we can be sure, the lead-up to their national convention that the Republican leadership planned for.  It is not the way they wanted to go into the fall campaign, which begins in just days now.  And Rep. Akin's refusal to resign has been a gift from heaven for the Democrats, who can continue to bring this sore subject up, time and again.  In the long run, it may not matter—but, it adds to the sense that the Republicans don't have their house in order and are doing everything they can to blow the coming presidential election.  We'll see.

The point here, however, is a different one.  Mr. Akin, it turns out, is a committed fundamentalist Christian and even has theological training.  The reason he steps on these land mines is partly because he is a true believer who feels an obligation to speak the truth as he sees it.  He honestly believes that liberals including even liberal Christians hate God.  He honestly believes that there are "illegitimate" rapes and that few women suffer serious consequences from being raped—or, he did.  Maybe he has actually learned differently from his gaffe.  Like many of the tea party right, he is engaged in a spiritual war against the enemies of God, which include his political opponents.  One wonders when the large majority of Americans will realize that the the threat of radicalism does not come from the left these days—certainly not from a pragmatic President who has upset the liberal wing of his party on more than one occasion.  It is the radical right that is the real threat to our democracy today, and Rep. Akin is a prime example of that threat.

Sunday, August 7, 2011

Idolatry & Ideology Follow Up

Idolatry seems like such an old-fashioned, time-worn concept, but it is coming back into vogue as a useful tool for theological analysis.  And it is beginning to be a thread in posts on this blog.  Recently, one of my other threads—the one that was following Rep. Todd Akin from Missouri—ended with the observation that faith tends to devolve into ideology, which is our modern form of biblical idolatry.  Recently, I came across an article by Chuck Colson, as conservative an evangelical as you could want, entitled, "Ideology and the Budget Deal," which makes much the same point although he doesn't use the word idolatry.  In that article, Colson briefly analyzes the recent debt ceiling brouhaha, and concludes,
What this debate has demonstrated is that America is deadlocked in a titanic ideological struggle. The danger is that without responsible leadership, deadlocked societies can descend quickly into chaos. And chaos can easily lead to tyranny.
As you have heard me say many times, and it bears repeating again and again, ideology is a man-made formulation: It is the enemy of true conservatism, which is governed by revealed truth and the wisdom of those who have gone before us. And it is certainly an enemy of the Gospel which rests on revealed propositional truth.
Colson's description of ideology as a dangerous product of the human mind is spot on.  The political gamesmanship during the debt ceiling debate showcased the dangers of ideology in a way that few Americans missed.  Maybe, we'll be a little more careful about the kind of people we elect to Congress next time around.  If we elect rigid ideologues, such as Rep. Akin, to public office, what we reap are the consequences, which are starkly those of  a contemporary form of idolatry that transforms faith into ideology.  By the way, I would add to Colson's comments that ideologies are also the enemies of true liberalism.

Friday, July 29, 2011

When Faith Becomes Ideology

Earlier, we followed the brief controversy Rep. Todd Akin, Republican of Missouri, sparked when he claimed that liberals hate God and want to replace God with big government. While there was a momentary furor esp. among the liberal bloggers and some progressive clergy in Missouri, the budding controversy has quietly gone away. I had thought there wouldn't be much more to write about the Senate candidate, but in the midst of the battle going on in Washington over the raising the debt ceiling, Akin has unfortunately provided further fodder for comment.

He opposes the compromise bill on the raising of the debt ceiling Speaker John Boehner tried to get through the House of Representatives, evidently because it is just that—a compromise. Speaking before a local Republican group back home, Akin accused President Obama of being "a flaming socialist" while the Republican caucus is "pretty conservative." And he is convinced that the debt ceiling is not that big of a deal. The government might slow down somewhat, but it won't collapse. He also referred to the economic stimulus package originally passed while President Bush was in office as "trash."  He may be right about raising the debt ceiling, but leading national and international economists disagree with him.  They think it is a big deal.

Akin is an ideological true believer, and as we saw in those previous posts his ideological base is an ultra conservative brand of Christian faith.  He, in fact, is a seminary graduate so that he cannot be accused of being ignorant of his faith.  And that is the point.  In his heart of hearts, Akin believes that liberals like the President and his Democratic "colleagues" in Congress are against God.  Being theologically trained, he knows that rebellion against God is the very essence of sin, so they are sinful.  They are necessarily evil or, at the very least, evil-ish.  For him to compromise with Democrats and liberals is not a matter just of politics but also of faith.  He can't do it.  It would be a betrayal of everything he holds sacred.

This is what happens when faith becomes ideological.  Instead of opening the heart, it closes one's ears.  Instead of promoting a compassion that is other-oriented, it gives birth to a self-involved, stubborn refusal to see the good in the other especially if that other is "a flaming socialist."  When faith becomes ideology, it is no longer faith.  It is idolatry, which is putting something crafted by the human mind in place of God.

For a similar (if less theological) & more detailed analysis, see Richard L. Fricker, "The Christian Right's Rigid Politics."

Saturday, July 9, 2011

A Sad P.S.

There's a sad postscript to the Akin versus liberals affair. According to a recent posting (here), Akin has added a political attack specialist to his campaign staff. This "gentleman" played a role in the "swift boat" attacks on John Kerry in 2004 and the attempt to hang the supposed radical, Bill Ayers, around President Obama's neck in 2008. This move sends clear signals about Akin's liberals hate God comment.  He meant it, isn't sorry for it other than the negative publicity it has gotten him, and intends to deal with that negative publicity by going on the attack.  This kind of scorched earth politics does our nation a huge disservice, and it is troubling that a man who professes a saving faith in Christ employs it.

Another Todd Akin Follow Up

In three RPK postings a few days back, I reported on the comment made by Rep. Todd Akin (R - MO) that liberals hate God and want to replace God with big government (see here, here, and here).  After refusing to apologize for the remark, he did make a limp apology.  And now he seems to be applying a strategy of not speaking about the incident, surely assuming that it will just go away if he doesn't add fuel to the fire. However, the story does continue to bounce around the Web a bit mostly on either Missouri websites or on liberal ones such as the Huffington Post (see here, for example).  Just yesterday, July 8th, Victoria Seigel posted a helpful list (here) of the various news outlets that have commented on the story.

In this light, Peter Wehner's posting, "Liberalism, Religion and the Enlightenment," is a notable contribution that goes beyond the right wing outrage sparking left wing outrage tone that has characterized most of the responses to Akin's inflammatory comment. Wehner is a self-styled conservative and agrees that liberalism generally is skeptical of religion and has even taken on an anti-religious tone at times. His analysis, however, is measured, seeks to be balanced, and refrains from the rhetoric of ideological outrage. He concludes the piece by writing,
As a general matter, liberals and conservatives view religion in the public square in very different ways, with many liberals alarmed at the prospect and many conservatives encouraged by it. Both sides have some historical justification for their views. But conservatives, in the here and now, have, I think, the much stronger case. The quickest way to undermine it is to make claims that are too sweeping and therefore false, the product of rage rather than reason. Which brings me full circle to Representative Akin’s comments, which didn’t do him, his cause, or his country any good.
This is what we need much more of in our public discourse: responsible, reasoned, and respectful commentary that can see why others think the way they do without necessarily agreeing with them.  Would that such comments were the norm rather than the exception.

Friday, July 1, 2011

One Last Stab: Todd Akin & Liberalism

The little chart that accompanies the results of Google news searches shows that by 6:00 pm Thursday, June 30, the story of Rep. Todd Akin's prejudicial, inflammatory statement that liberals hate God and want to replace God with big government (see my previous posting) had lost what media legs it ever had—which wasn't much, really.  While certain progressive sites and writers took up the hue and cry, most of the nation never noticed the story at all.  It never made it into CNN, for example, and even the on line religious news websites ignored it.  It has taken place so far in advance of next year's primary elections that it will surely have no impact on Akin's bid for the Senate.

Now, Rep. Akin may have learned that he has to be more careful about public expressions of his prejudices about liberals, but it is hardly likely that he unlearned the prejudice.   His remarks were reprehensible from a liberal perspective, but he still holds them.  The liberal hue and cry, such as it was, didn't even begin to address them.  Akin is right-wing indignant that NBC dropped "under God" from the pledge of allegiance. The liberal Missouri clergy that delivered a letter of reprimand to his staff (source) are left-wing indignant at his prejudice and his failure to care for America's poor.  Akin himself refused to meet with the clergy, who at least wanted to talk—not that it would have done much good.  And no lessons were learned.

Everybody's talking and nobody's listening.  Both sides are clearly fearful and angry.  Nobody's addressing the fears.  Instead, Akin demonizes the liberals who demonize him.  I understand that for the sake of truth as they understand it and conscience , progressives could not let Akin's statement pass unanswered.  Silence was not a choice.  It's just sad that their responses have left us exactly where we were before: standing on the opposite sides of an apparently unbridgeable chasm.  There must be a better way.

(For further reflection on the vexing problem of cross-ideological communication, check out Peter Laarman, "Why Liberal Religious Arguments Fail," at rdmagazine.)

Thursday, June 30, 2011

Rep. Akin Follow-up

Under the posting title, "These Are Sad Times," this past Tuesday I shared with readers the comment made by Rep. Todd Akin (R - MO) that liberals at heart are God-haters who want to replace God with big government.  He made the comment last Friday.  Monday, he refused to apologize for it, but then on Tuesday he made one of those non-apology apologies that essentially means he still believes liberalism breeds God-hating (source).

Today,  three United Church of Christ clergy leaders plus a Unitarian Universalist cleric plan to deliver a letter of protest to Rep. Akin.  The text of the letter reads,
"As Missourians of faith, we found your statement that "at the heart of liberalism really is a hatred of God and a belief that government should replace God" to be ignorant and offensive. Scripture clearly warns us to "judge not, lest ye be judged," yet you condemn in disrespectful, stereotypical terms those with whom you disagree. Such insulting pronouncements degrade our nation's political dialogue and are unworthy of a public servant who claims to represent the interests of all of his constituents.
"And in light of your support for a federal budget that mainstream faith leaders have overwhelmingly condemned as punitive toward the poorest among us, we call on you to reconsider not only your words, but also your moral priorities as a political leader. Accusing others of being inspired by hatred of God while you vote to deprive the weakest and most vulnerable of medicine and basic sustenance is the antithesis of moral leadership. We call on you to apologize, and we pray that you are moved to act in a spirit of civility, compassion and justice in the future." (source)
Talk about ships passing in the night.  This is a classic example.  Given the judgmental tone of the clergy response, the bit about not judging so you won't get judged probably could have been best dropped.  And while the statement about Akin's voting record may be as the letter describes it, Akin could argue that his votes are not against the poor but for fiscal responsibility, which is also a moral issue.  The letter's moral indignation at his voting record echoes Akin's moral indignation at liberalism, although it is targeted much more narrowly and doesn't make blanket statements about conservatives.  Still, it is an expression of liberal indignation hitting back at Akin's conservative indignation at NBC's removal of "under God" from the pledge of allegiance.

Both Akin and the clergy are committed Christians. who seem to be better at preaching than listening, which is a weakness we all share no matter what our political ideology or theology.  We do not seem to be able to temper our ideologies and theologies for the sake of mutual forbearance and reconciliation—for the sake of the Gospel.  If well-intentioned followers of Christ cannot find ways past their politics, how can we expect others to do so?  These are indeed sad times.

Tuesday, June 28, 2011

These Are Sad Times

Comments that Rep. Todd Akin, Republican of Missouri, made in a recent radio interview are beginning to catch fire in the media and threaten to "go viral."  In response to a question about NBC's leaving "under God" out of the pledge of allegiance recently, Akin observed that, "Well, I think NBC has a long record of being very liberal and at the heart of liberalism really is a hatred for God and a belief that government should replace God. And so they’ve had a long history of not being at all favorable toward many of the things that have been such a blessing to our country." Akin is currently seeking the Republican nomination for the Senate seat now held by Sen. Claire McCaskill (D - MO).

Missouri Democrats have grabbed onto Todd's comment hoping to use it to their political advantage. Meanwhile, progressive Christian and Jewish leaders are defending their faith in the face of what they take to be Todd's ignorance and prejudice.  While the reactions of both Democrats and progressive religious folks are understandable, there is something painfully sad about the whole incident.

Rep. Akin's comments and his later reaffirmation of them are but a further revelation of the fearful anger that is so prevalent in our national life today.  We see it in the tea party movement.  We see it in the debates over abortion, gay rights, and even raising the ceiling on the national debt.  An important element of our population is frightened and angry.  People who think differently are no longer neighbors but enemies of the nation—and of God.  And while the fear and anger seems to be especially strong on the right wing of our politics, the left wing reacts in kind, fans it, and seeks to use it to political advantage where it can.  Prejudice breeds fear, fear breeds anger, anger breeds but deeper prejudice, and the whole vicious cycle fractures our political system—renders it ineffectual.

And in it all, the actual teachings of Jesus are lost to all of us including those who sincerely intend to defend those teachings.  When Rep. Akin speaks about liberals, we do not hear in his voice the love for neighbor that Christ taught.  It is a simple truth, we defend Christ only when we speak with kindness, love, and a willingness to forgive and be reconciled.  These are the fundamental values of the New Testament.  What is truly sad is that Rep. Akin is a seminary graduate—Presbyterian no less—and knows all of this.  Somewhere along the line, however, his politics seems to have trumped his faith, at least in his rhetoric.  And one can only wonder how Rep. Todd thinks he is qualified to represent the liberal residents of Missouri in the Senate, if elected to that high office.  That, after all, is what he must do if elected—represent all of his constituents liberal as well as conservative.  How can he possibly represent the hundreds of thousands of Missourians that he believes are God-haters?  How can he practice the art of compromise in the Senate if he is convinced that liberal Democrats from places like New York are enemies of his faith and his nation?  These are sad times.

Sources for this posting: