We should maintain that if an interpretation of any word in any religion leads to disharmony and does not positively further the welfare of the many, then such an interpretation is to be regarded as wrong; that is, against the will of God, or as the working of Satan or Mara.

Buddhadasa Bikkhu, a Thai Buddhist Monk


Wednesday, February 13, 2013

Paul's Four Commandments for Church Life

Paul's second letter to the Corinthians, as we have it in the New Testament, closes with a brief set of injunctions on how the Jesus community in Corinth should carry forward.  Working from several English-language translations and paraphrases, however, II Corinthians 13:11 seems confusing.  The translators and paraphrasers render the verse in quite different ways.  For example:

  • American Standard Version (ASV): "Finally, brethren, farewell. Be perfected; be comforted; be of the same mind; live in peace: and the God of love and peace shall be with you."

  • New Revised Standard Version (NRSV): "Finally, brothers and sisters, farewell. Put things in order, listen to my appeal, agree with one another, live in peace; and the God of love and peace will be with you."

  • Today's English Version (TEV): "And now, my friends, good-bye! Strive for perfection; listen to my appeals; agree with one another; live in peace. And the God of love and peace will be with you."

  • The Message (MSG): "And that’s about it, friends. Be cheerful. Keep things in good repair. Keep your spirits up. Think in harmony. Be agreeable. Do all that, and the God of love and peace will be with you for sure. Greet one another with a holy embrace. All the brothers and sisters here say hello."

  • Laughing Bird Paraphrases (LB): "Sisters and brothers, I finish my letter by wishing you every joy and offering these last words: ........- get everything on track; ........- take courage from what I’ve said; ........- seek consensus; ........- live in peace."
To take just the first injunction: being perfected (ASV), putting things in order (NRSV), striving for perfection (TEV), keeping things in good order (MSG), and "getting everything on track" (LB) are not all the same thing at all.  Wright's Kingdom New Testament translates this injunction as "put everything in order."  The old J.B. Phillip's translation takes a different tack, "live in harmony."

The other injunctions are similarly variously translated or paraphrased.  Taken together, however, we come out with something like this:  (1) Paul called on the brothers and sisters in Corinth to get their act together and move from a disorderly life together to one that is more orderly.  (2) He enjoined them to pay attention to his advice to them and take comfort from his words.  (3) They were to reach a meeting of the minds on the key issues facing them in their life together.  They were to live in peace with each other.

We might call these Paul's Four Commandments for Church Life and summarize them more briefly as: [1] strive for a clean political process; [2] pay attention to scripture; [3] work for consensus; and [4] in all things behave peaceably.  Do these things, and the God of peace and love will be manifest among you.  That is, first, as a church works through differences it should do so openly and without political games, attempts to coerce members into a forced agreement, or dividing into contentious factions.  Second, just as Paul called on the Corinthians to heed his advice, which should have carried the weight of apostolic authority for them, so we should pay special attention to the Bible as our source of authoritative guidance.  Third, the goal of the members of the church is always to seek a meeting of the minds where points of difference or even conflict occur.  We can take this to mean that church members seek to understand each other's viewpoints and concerns, seek to discover consensus in their differences, and not allow differences to  destroy their deeper unity in Christ.  Finally, the fourth commandment sums up the intent of the first three: live in peace.  Where churches follow these four commandments, the Spirit will be clearly present in them.   Amen.

Tuesday, February 12, 2013

Jesus & the Successful Pastor

The Christian Post website recently posted an editorial entitled, "The Recipe for a Successful Pastor," which caught my eye because I knew instinctively even before I read the posting that I would find it a "challenge".  There is a huge literature out there today dedicated to unlocking the secret(s) to a successful pastorate, and I have to confess that I have given up on it for the most part.  In my experience, capable pastors generally don't benefit from all of the insights, real and supposed, contained in the literature while less than capable ones are usually not able to apply those insights.  And there are some things you can't teach, such as when to address conflict and when to leave it alone, which is one of the most important skills any pastor has to develop.  So, a brief article purporting to provide the recipe for pastoral success can inspire only skepticism from the get-go.

In this case, the author contends that the key to pastoral success lies in heart of the pastor. The article states, "The pastor must be enthralled by, in awe of, and in love with his Redeemer so that everything he thinks, desires, chooses, decides, says, and does is propelled by love for Christ and the security of rest in the love of Christ."  Or again, "Only love for Christ can defend the heart of the pastor against all other loves that have the potential to kidnap his ministry." That is, "Only the glory of the risen Christ will guard him against the self-glory that tempts all and destroys the ministry of so many." The article concludes, "Thankfulness for the grace of Christ expresses itself in grace to others. Gratitude for the patience and forgiveness of Christ enables you to be patient and forgiving of others. Your daily experience of the rescue of the gospel gives you a passion for people experiencing the same rescue. This is the soil in which true ministry success grows."

In short, the recipe for a successful pastorate is to be profoundly in love with Christ.  That love will flower into humility, patience, a forgiving heart, and a passion for service that is the bedrock of pastoral ministry.

There is no little truth in this recipe for success so far as it goes, but the problem is that it doesn't take us very far.  There are any number of pastors, even some whose churches are overflowing with members, who profess this love of Christ and yet are not successful in their pastorates.  That is, they demonstrate that arrogant "humility" and self-important "selflessness" that is always the danger of the intensely pious pastor.  The very intensity of their apparent love of Christ is a mask for an underlying idolatry that transforms that love into self-love.  Such pastors can do immeasurable damage to people because they appear to be selfless servants of the Lord but aren't.

Let us grant, however, that there are pastors who do feel this deep love of Christ in a liberating way.  They are humble, patient, forgiving, and passionate in their ministry.  This is all to the good, but it does not guarantee success in pastoral ministry.  This love of Christ may be a condition for a successful pastorate, but it is not a recipe for one.  There are times when one must put humility aside and not wait on patience.  There are times when passion for ministry is a recipe for burnout rather than success.  And there are times when a pastor has to confront bad behaviors that have been forgiven too often.

This injunction to have a heart filled with love for Christ can lead pastors in one of two dangerous directions.  In some (perhaps many) it can breed self-doubt, anxiety, and a feeling of inadequacy.  Love of Christ is like all loves, stronger some days and weeks weaker on others.  We can't maintain intense emotions, such as expected in this posting, for long periods of time.  The question will haunt the honest pastor, "Do I really love Christ so deeply?"  In others, as mentioned above, the sense that the pastor deeply loves Christ can breed the arrogance of one who "has it made" with the Lord.  I'm not sure that the level of enthrallment proposed in the article is even healthy, mentally or spiritually.  It sounds almost like an addiction, and we are not called to be addicted to Christ.  Addictions are self-destructive whatever the substance abused might be.

Finally, the article does not address at all the question of what "success" means in pastoral ministry or how it is measured.  One of the truths that drives many out of pastoral ministry is that both the measure and the assurance that one is serving successfully is an illusive, ever-receding mirage.

In sum, in a literature that is generally not helpful articles like this are particularly unhelpful.

Monday, February 11, 2013

In the Spirit—and Liberal

Anugrah Kumar's recent editorial, "How Should a Reformed Pastor Be Charismatic?" raises important questions for liberal pastors and moderately not conservative churches, namely the role of the Holy Spirit in vital church life and how we perceive that role. Kumar's editorial reports and reflects on a speech given by a pastor from the U.K., Tope Koleoso, who opened his speech with the claim that church leaders should "understand and exercise the gifts of the Holy Spirit while shunning fanaticism." He then raised the question, "why would anyone who is Bible-believing, Christ-centered and theology-loving be hesitant, cautious or resistant to the Holy Spirit?" Koleoso wants pastors and churches to engage in faith-healing, teach the power of the Holy Spirit, deliver people from "demonic forces," and rely more explicitly on the power of the Spirit. He cited the example of the early church, which "did not know discipleship that was apart from the filling of the Holy Spirit." He concluded that it does not matter what faith tradition a pastor comes from; pastors and churches need "to be filled with the Holy Spirit daily."

To be filled by the Holy Spirit, Koleoso claimed, "means to be restored to the initial intention so that you once again have the relation and resources." It is an ongoing process that puts God at the center of things. In the Spirit, one longs for God's presence as the one central concern of ministry and preaching. And when pastors and churches are filled by the Spirit and long for God, "things begin to happen … [God] begins to speak to the people … give gifts to them … the gifts begin to come forth … the word of knowledge, the word of wisdom, prophecy, tongues, interpretation, gifts of healing, gift of faith."

Protestant church culture in America today is heavily influenced by the evangelical and charismatic/pentecostal wing(s) of American Protestantism.  That influence has a dark side for those of us who are not part of that wing.  But it also has its beneficial side, if only we have the wit to separate the wheat from the chaff.  Among other things, evangelicals and pentecostals have brought the Holy Spirit into prominence, and they are correct when they insist that a church cannot be healthy without the Spirit.  In mainline churches, we may not engage in faith-healing of physical ailments or speak in tongues, but it still takes the work of the Spirit to infuse our worship with life, small groups with enthusiasm, and individuals with spiritual healing.  It takes the Spirit to turn conflict into reconciliation.  It takes the Spirit, frankly, to restore healthy vibrancy to declining mainline churches.

Whether interpreted literally or liberally, the Spirit still can speak through the Bible—inspire it.  The work of the Spirit is not limited by our theologies.  The Spirit persistently lurks in mainline sanctuaries as much as it does in pentecostal ones and tugs at liberal hearts as insistently as it does evangelical ones.  The story of the early churches in Acts is the story of the Spirit at work among those churches.  Our story can be and should be but another chapter in that same tale of the Spirit.  The thing is liberal-ish preachers and moderately not conservative churches need to begin to focus on the theme of the Spirit and even go so far as to pray for its manifest (rather than latent) presence.  And things do happen.  Amen.

Saturday, February 9, 2013

A Good Pastor Makes for a Happy Church - Really?

The Christian Post recently posted a column entitled, "Nine Characteristics of Happy Churches," which is little short of eye-opening.  Of the nine characteristics listed, five have to do with the pastor, one with the way business meetings are conducted, and one other has to do with the church staff.  That is, seven of the nine are about the pastor and/or her leadership team.  Only two are directly related to the church's members distinct from its pastor, namely involvement in ministry and in a small group.  When a substantial number of members are engaged in those two activities, the church is more likely to be happy.  Otherwise, the person and style of the pastor is the key to a happy church.

If only it were that easy.  There is no question but that the leadership style and the personality of the pastor is one important factor in church health.  That statement, however, is equally true of the followership style and personality of the congregation she serves.  Churches are a blending of personalities, sometimes inherently quite healthy and sometimes not so much.  Thus, the same pastor with the same personality can have a healthy, happy relationship with one church and then move on to a relationship in the next church that turns out to be dysfunctional.  A church, by the same token, can get along very happily with one pastor but then not the next.

Interestingly enough, the listed characteristic overlooks the presence and influence of the Spirit in a congregation's life.  Before all else, a church where the whole leadership of the congregation, including pastoral,  is mutually committed to spirituality is a church that is more likely to be healthy and happy.

It is lists like this, to be frank, that infect pastors with both hubris and anxiety.  In spite of this list's fixation with pastoral leadership, church health is not all about the pastor.  It is about a healthy relationship between a church and its pastor grounded in the Spirit.  That is a three-way relationship.  In this relationship, church members exercise significant leadership, the pastor knows when to lead and when to follow, and the Holy Spirit is a Presence in the interpersonal and institutional dynamics of the whole congregation.  Things are not all sweetness and light in such a church, but on any given Sunday morning its sanctuary will hum with health and its singing will be infested with the Spirit.  Without a good pastor, a happy church will not happen.  Without a good church, it will not happen.  Without the Spirit, it cannot happen.  Amen.

Friday, February 8, 2013

The God That Is Not God

"God the Father" by Ludovico Mazzolino (1480–1530)
Source: Wikipedia
Michael Dowd's book, Thank God for Evolution, raises one of the key theological issues of our day, namely our understanding of the nature of God.  Dowd especially points to a God that resides within the Universe and is the Sum Total, the Whole of the Universe.  He argues, "From a holy evolutionary perspective, God is no longer envisioned as a supreme landlord residing off the planet and outside the Universe.  This ancient view of the divine is now much too small to embrace the vast, intricate, and nuanced realities that have been revealed by science in the past few hundred years." (paperback edition, p. 87).

While word meanings can be fluid and change over time, the usual definition of the word, "God," is, "the one Supreme Being, the creator and ruler of the universe."  In 2013, we can agree that God is indeed not "a supreme landlord," nor is God a Santa/Grandfather like figure peering over the rim of the Universe and pulling our strings.  It seems, however, that envisioning a God that does not reside outside of the Universe is pretty much throwing the baby out with the bath water.  It begs the question of origins, that is the question of how All Of This came to be.  It also gives too much hermeneutical power to science, which for Dowd is the chief vehicle of "divine revelation" in our age.  That is to say, at the moment we are aware of an amazing set of parameters in our Universe that make it uniquely suited to life on Earth and which, otherwise, defy odds so great as to make the existence of this universe virtually miraculous.  We are aware of an incredible set of evolutionary processes within the Universe, which exhibit an almost holy level of ongoing creativity that on the face of it has direction and feels purposeful.  Finally, embedded deep within us is an equally holy sense of awe at the Beyond, however we name it, a sense experienced by those who deny any possibility of a Supreme Being as well as by those who have faith in One.

For me, personally, our religious traditions and the findings of science together point to God, who/that is at once Beyond and Present.  Meta-science may one day attain a better understanding of God than is possible for us today—assuming, of course, that the human race survives its own creative but chaotic evolutionary experience long enough to move beyond science to whatever will come next.  Until such time as we discover a deeper understanding of God than is now possible to us, we live in faith.  (Once we find that "deeper understanding" what we may also find is that faith is still the only way to live because faith is not believing in something we can't see - it is a life-orientation).

The idea that God does not transcend the Universe feels like a detour down a dead end street.  We can affirm that God is not a great big landlord in the sky.  God is not a bearded Granddaddy or Santa Writ Large.  Still, given what we know now living in faith that there is a Creator, both Beyond and Present, is a viable option validated by our sense of God's Presence in the Spirit in our life of faith.  Anything less feels inadequate to the Created nature of the Universe and our deepest experiences of the Holy.

Wednesday, February 6, 2013

Keep 'Em Honest

19th c. Indian pandits
Source:  Kamat's Potpourri
Here's a fun website that I came across just recently: PunditTracker: Bringing Accountability to the Prediction Industry.  You can select your favorite pundit and find out how well she or he does at predicting the future.  It has two tracks, one for political pundits and one for sports.  Check it out, if you want to add a bit of entertaining distraction to your day.

According to Wikipedia, the term "pundit" comes from a Sanskrit word, pandit.  In English, it refers to "...someone who offers to mass media his or her opinion or commentary on a particular subject area (most typically political analysis, the social sciences or sport) on which they are usually knowledgeable (or can at least appear to be knowledgeable)."  In modern Indian usage, it means a, "...scholar and a teacher, particularly one skilled in the Sanskrit language, who has mastered the four Vedic scriptures, Hindu rituals, Hindu law, religion, music, and/or philosophy under a Guru in a Gurukul or has been tutored under the ancient vedic Guru Shishya academic tradition."  In Thai, pandit (บัณฑิต), is widely used in education circles to signify someone who has received a college or university degree. Its wider meaning recalls its Sanskrit origin, i.e. a person of wisdom and learning, a sage.

According to dictionary.com (here), the British introduced the word into the English language from Hindi in the late 17th century, and it did not begin to take on its current meaning until the later 19th century—perhaps beginning with a social club at Yale.

Tuesday, February 5, 2013

The Choice of Our Times

In all of the major issues currently being debated in Congress and in the nation, our choice is not essentially between liberal and conservative answers to those questions. The choice we face, rather, is between a politics of engagement and one of imposition.  Engaged politics can be rough and tumble, but in the end it consciously works for solutions arrived it out of the engagement of many viewpoints in a process of give and take.  At its best engagement politics rests on mutual respect and shared concerns, no matter how differently expressed or even perceived those concerns might be.  Imposition politics is one-sided, ideological, and built on disdain. It appears to be the stronger of the two approaches, because it seems to be grounded on unbending principles and unalterable attitudes.  In fact, it totters uncertainly on the shifting sands of our worst political natures while engagement politics, for all of its uncertainties, tends to find solid ground in an underlying unity of purpose.  Engaged politics creates partners, however shaky their alliances might be, while imposition politics sparks intense, angry, and even bitter resistance.

The tea party, so called, represents one of the clearest expressions of imposition politics in recent American politics.  As such, it offers Americans an important opportunity to reaffirm our core shared commitment to a constitutional form of government built on engagement with each other regarding the great issues of our day.  Just as an infection can leave a body with enhanced antibodies, so resistance to the tea party movement could well strengthen our democracy and make us better practitioners of a more honest, open, and engaged politics.  Amen.

Monday, February 4, 2013

Peace

Black Elk & Family, ca. 1910
Source:  Wikiquote
The first peace, which is the most important, is that which comes within the souls of people when they realize their relationship, their oneness, with the universe and all its powers, and when they realize that at the center of the universe dwells Wakan-Tanka [Great Spirit], and that this center is really everywhere, it is within each of us. This is the real peace, and the others are but reflections of this. The second peace is that which is made between two individuals, and the third is that which is made between two nations. But above all you should understand that there can never be peace between nations until there is known that true peace, which, as I have often said, is within the souls of men.

Black Elk,
The Sacred Pipe : Black Elk's Account of the Seven Rites of the Oglala Sioux (1953)

Saturday, February 2, 2013

A Sad, Sad Headline

Darlene Sitler (1959-2012)
This morning, the Huffington Post opens the day with a sad headline, "THE PRICE OF 'FREEDOM'," along with the photos of 100 individuals who have died from gun violence in America since the Sandy Hook murders. The article to which that headline links is entitled, "U.S. Gun Deaths Since Sandy Hook Top 1,280."  The article itself chronicles just a handful of those shooting deaths.

The list of  dead does not include Darlene Sitler, choir director of First United Presbyterian Church, Coudersport, PA, who was murdered while playing the organ during worship on Sunday, December 2, 2012, twelve days before Sandy Hook. See reports of her death, at the hand of her ex-husband, (here),  (here), and (here).  Darlene was a local music teacher and by all accounts loved and respected.  She was 53 at the time of her death.

The gun control laws now being discussed probably would not have her life as her killer used a handgun and the shooting was without any prior warning that he would do such a thing.  But, that does not mean that we as a society should not continue to try to reduce and reduce again the havoc we are wrecking on each other with guns.  As is being noted in the current debate over gun control, it is true that guns do not kill.  It is also true that violent, angry, demented, or just plain heartless people use guns to kill—by the tens of thousands every year in America.

It already seems clear that in the current political environment only a limited amount can be done to curb gun violence legislatively.  That is sad.  One fears that it is going to take another Sandy Hook and one after that and perhaps one after that to move legislation along. How much heartache we are going to endure before even a minimum of common sense moves us to begin the task of bringing gun violence under control?  The Second Amendment was intended to preserve our right to form militias not provide the opportunity to gun each other down in the streets.  Its modern expansion to include exactly that by its more radical "defenders" defies all spiritual as well as humane common sense.  Sadly so.

Friday, February 1, 2013

Is "Something" Happening?

There is a lot that is wrong with the world.  It can be depressing sometimes and with reason.  But...at other times it feels like just maybe "something" is happening—a fundamental change is taking place that might bode well for the future.  There are trends, such as the drop in crime rates in the United States, and the significant decrease in international warfare since the end of the Cold War, that suggest that maybe "something" is happening.  In various parts of the world, there are a growing number of projects aimed at preserving and even restoring natural biodiversity including some successful projects in island restoration.  Back in October, the Christian Science Monitor reported (here) on an ambitious international project aimed at protecting "10 percent of coastal and marine waters [of the world's oceans] as marine-protected areas by 2020."  Scattered across the media, there are many, many little indications that "something" larger may be happening.

The latest tidbit (for me, anyway) is a Time NewsFeed article entitled, "Beer Drinking in Germany Hits a Record Low," which reports exactly what its title says: beer drinking in Germany is declining.  The article suggests that Germans, who traditionally have consumed huge amounts of beer, are becoming more health-conscious, exercising more, and drinking beer less.  This is true of younger Germans as well.  While other forms of alcohol have become more popular, the overall trend seems to be toward less fattening consumption.  On a global scale this is not a big deal, but it suggests larger changes in values and attitudes that may be a big deal.  One thinks of the rapidly growing acceptance of the LGBT community in the United States as another one of those trends, more significant than a decline in German beer drinking, but also suggestive of a change in attitudes and values—a good one, leading to better personal and social health as a decline in beer drinking leads to better physical health.

Other trends may overwhelm the "something" that is happening, especially the continued decline of our global biosphere and the increasing ravages of global warming.  But, maybe not.  Maybe, just maybe, the in-spirited waves of evolution are carrying us forward to "something" new.  Amen.