We should maintain that if an interpretation of any word in any religion leads to disharmony and does not positively further the welfare of the many, then such an interpretation is to be regarded as wrong; that is, against the will of God, or as the working of Satan or Mara.

Buddhadasa Bikkhu, a Thai Buddhist Monk


Thursday, August 31, 2017

Matthew 8:1-4 -- Mark's version is better

So, we begin a new section of the gospel, which features Jesus' healing miracles just as the previous section (Matt. 5-7) featured his teachings.  The compiler/author begins this section with what can only be called a strange healing, a head-scratcher of sorts.  The story has Jesus coming down from the hills with a large crowd following him and then, without any transition in the story a man "with a dreaded skin disease" kneels before him and tells Jesus that if Jesus wants to he can heal this guy.  Jesus said he did want and then did.  And then, Jesus tells him to go to a priest, get himself certified as clean, and then sponsor a sacrifice—but, says Jesus, don't tell anyone.  Don't tell anyone?  What happened to the crowd?  And, why not tell anyone?  Isn't the whole point of Jesus' ministry to communicate good news of liberation by word and deed?

Scholars struggle to answer these questions, but at the end of the day there's something a little unsatisfying about this story whatever their explanations.   There is just one loose end too many however we cut it.  It helps, I think, to check out the earlier version of the story in Mark 1:40-45.  There the tale is much the same except for the ending.  In Mark, the guy who is healed went off and, having been ordered to be silent, proceeds to tell everyone and their uncle about Jesus.  In fact, he talked so much to so many that Jesus couldn't walk through town without being swamped by the crowd.  Instead, he had to go out into the country-side, and even then large crowds flocked to him.

Some scholars argue that Matthew drops Mark's ending because it is disrespectful of Jesus, a kind of undercutting of his authority.  The healed guy is more or less shown to be the star of the story, praiseworthy for his faith in Jesus and for his enthusiastic evangelistic endeavours in spite of the fact that he failed to do what Jesus instructed him to do.  The compiler of Matthew, so this argument goes, simply couldn't accept this diminishing of Jesus,' authority.  We don't know if this speculation is correct, of course, but if it is it only serves to underscore a point I made in a previous post (here) that Matthew reflects the thinking of a particular party within the early Jesus Movement.  It was a party that was already moving toward a more exalted view of the person of Christ.

But I like Mark.  Jesus' sanctity didn't need defending; and what is impressive in the story is the kind of fearless, open faith he excited in the man.  And Mark's story makes more sense.  The reason it has Jesus admonishing the guy not to tell anyone he's been healed is to highlight the extent of his subsequent elation.  Being healed of a "dreaded skin disease" was a big deal.  He had been exiled from home, family, and community and forced to live a degraded existence.  Suddenly, he could go home.  He was free!  Amazing!  Awesome!  He was so fired-up, so elated that he just couldn't keep what happened to him to himself.  He had to tell the story.

Piety isn't all it is cracked up to be.  It can be so straight-laced, so worried about right thinking, and so protective of its doctrines that it quashes things that matter because they don't seem to be pious enough.  Mark is ambiguous.  Matthew isn't.  And it is in Mark we get a happy, almost hilarious description of true faith in Jesus—a faith so exuberant that it won't let even the Rabbi himself silence it.  That seems contradictory.  It is counter-intuitive.  It is so typically human.  Mark thus celebrates what Matthew frowns on as wrong, bad, un-Christian.  Spoil-sport!  Mark's version is better.  Amen.

Wednesday, August 30, 2017

Matthew 8-9 - Another Dimension

Where Matthew 5-7 is widely recognized as a unit, the so-called sermon on the mount, chapter 8-9 are not as often seen that way, at least by the average reader.  But they are.  The author, having set forth a compendium of Jesus' teachings, now provides us with a series of examples of Jesus' skills as a healer.  In the summary statement at the end of the section (9:35-38), the compiler/author observes that Jesus had a two-fold ministry, teaching about the Kingdom and then demonstrating its reality through healing.  The author then avows that Jesus did all of this because he was profoundly touched at a gut level—the meaning of the Greek word, esplanchnisthē (ἐσπλαγχνίσθη)—by the pitiable state of the people who lived in anxiety and seemed to be like lost sheep in need of a shepherd.

Where Matthew 5-7 summarized Jesus' teachings to those in need, we now move into a section of two chapters (8-9) that show how Jesus responded to their needs, which was to alleviate their suffering.  In our terms, Jesus was both a prophet and a humanitarian.  The point of concern here is not with miraculous healing per se.  In the first century, people believed in such things and concerned themselves with miracles for what they demonstrated, which was (holy) power and authority.  In this case, his miracles actually demonstrated a deep concern on Jesus' part to alleviate suffering, and if the author's portrait of him is correct Jesus does not seem to have been concerned with proving anything about himself.  He exercised holy power and authority on behalf of people in need.

In later years, Christians became fixated with the power and authority of Jesus Christ, the Son of God.  They pointed to his miracles as proof of his divinity.  Then, still later, doubters and skeptics ridiculed the whole idea of such miracles as being largely Christian propaganda and superstitious nonsense.  The first century message so clearly set out in Matthew that Jesus taught and healed out of a prophetic and humanitarian concern for the Jewish people of his day was largely lost, especially when it came to the healing miracles.  Insisting, thus, that the miracles "really happened," literally, as described in the Bible misses their point entirely.  They are not a proof of the truth of the Christian religion and the Bible.  In the first century, they knew that miracles took place and nobody argued that point.  In our age, whether we "believe in miracles" or not is irrelevant to the message of the gospel and obscures its original intent, which was to emphasise that Jesus was not your ordinary attention-grabbing charlatan.  If Matthew is an accurate portrayal of Jesus, he was not motivated by power or the desire for attention.  He was "the real deal" because of his compassion for others, demonstrated both in the way he taught and in his ability to heal others in dire need.  Amen.

Monday, August 28, 2017

Matthew 7:28-29 - Blown Away

Matthew's compilation of Jesus' teachings that we call the "sermon on the mount" concludes with these two verses (7:28-29), which state that "the crowd" had their minds blown away by his teaching. He knew what he was talking about unlike the teachers' of the law who, apparently, seemed just to be blowing smoke most of the time.  That comparison is important because it was about politics as much as about religion, there being no distinction between the two in that era.

As we read through the gospel, I've been making some noise about its political nature and implications.  Partly, we need to be reminded that it contains real world stuff, CNN headlines material.  Partly, as we can see here, Jesus' political context clearly mattered to the compiler/author .  These two verses are not from Jesus himself.  They are editorial material that claim to represent the thinking of "the crowd".  They don't have to be here, but here they are; and 7:29 makes it clear that the public was comparing Jesus to the religious big shots and finding the big shots wanting.  Those big shots were as much political leaders as they were religious teachers, and very soon they would begin to react to what they perceived as Jesus' challenge to their power (see Matt. 9:3).  If the author didn't think this political stuff wasn't important, he or she wouldn't keep reminding us about it.

One thing that made Jesus so politically potent was the mind-blowing way in which he spoke.  The Greek word that I've translated as "mind-blowing" here, according to Biblehub.com, is ekplésso (ἐκπλήσσω), which means being utterly amazed, dumbfounded, or left at a loss for words by something that causes one to gape in astonishment. In first century Palestine, a country-bumpkin self-appointed rabbi stepped out on thin ice when he blew the minds of his audience.  That made the powers that be look bad and, more importantly, suggested that the rabbi could become a political player, an agitator of the public.

We can imagine that small church in some city in the eastern Mediterranean listening to the gospel being read for the first time and thinking to themselves right about now, "Oh, oh, this could be a problem."  Their interest would have been piqued.  They knew the outcome, but not the details.  Now, things started to make sense.  The gospel was revealing to them the first steps on the way to the cross.

Sunday, August 27, 2017

Matthew 7:13-27 - The Real Jesus

The Jesus Movement was, obviously, about Jesus.  It began as a Jewish sectarian movement, which quickly spread beyond Judaism—to Samaria and into Gentile territories.  It was a movement, which meant that it was only loosely organized and no one was really in control.  Being part of such a movement can be an exhilarating experience—and it can be worrisome because things can get out of hand.  These passages remind us that one of the reasons the compiler/author of Matthew wrote the gospel was because things were getting out of hand.  All sorts of ideas about Jesus were being bandied about.  Some taught that he was just a rabbi, though a very good one.  Others claimed he was super-human to one degree or another.  And there were many other positions in-between.

The author, in this section of the gospel, wants her or his readers to understand that the Jesus presented in the gospel was the real Jesus.  Don't listen to other renditions of him!  If you do, you are not walking through the narrow gate.  You are building your house on sand.  You are eating sour fruit, and on That Day Jesus himself will reject you.  Not everyone who proclaims Jesus' name is worthy of listening to or following after.  Follow the Jesus you find here in this gospel!

Matthew was a party document.  It was a reasoned, persuasive presentation of one understanding of who the "real" Jesus was, which eventually became part of the basis of orthodox Christianity in the early church.  It's Christology became an expression of the standard theology about Christ, which is why we still have it today.

The point is that Matthew can be (and was) a "party document" and a place in which we hear the Spirit speaking to us.  We believe that God was incarnate in Jesus of Nazareth, the Christ, but that does not mean that God was/is/will be incarnate only in Jesus.  Incarnation, instead, is the way God the Spirit is present with us, working in an amazing array of ways to inspire us forward.  I know I've made this point already, but we need to remind ourselves regularly that the whole idea of incarnation means that the Spirit works through human beings and their institutions, languages, cultures, and life ways to the end that we willingly, independently have faith in God.

So, among other things, the Spirit is present in and speaks through a first-century document written originally to put forward one faction's views of Jesus.  Thank God.

Saturday, August 26, 2017

Matthew 7:13-27- Dualism

Matthew was written at some point in the late first century, 1,900-plus years ago.  The complier/author's goal was to present a selection of the sayings and doings of Jesus useful to the churches of the Jesus Movement.  The author did not have us in mind.  She wrote for his time, not ours.  Understanding that we are not going to get any closer to the actual Jesus than the three synoptic gospels (Mark, Matthew, & Luke), we need to read them critically and even selectively.  Not everything in there is helpful to us today.

Speaking personally, one of the things I find difficult is the dualism of the whole of the Bible, both testaments.  We see that dualism in today's passages.  There is a narrow gate and a broad one.  There are healthy trees and fruit-less ones.  There are those who will enter the Kingdom and those wicked people who will not.  Wise individuals build on rock, stupid ones build on sand.  There is good; there is evil.  Nothing in between.  Right - Wrong.  The Kingdom - hell.  Wisdom - Folly.  Nothing in between.  This is dualism, and dualism is a human ideology.  Dualism is about building walls.    Dualists deal with opposition through judgment, pointed debates, oppositional politics, and even violence "when necessary."  Dualists do not compromise because compromise is a sin.  They do not dialogue, because the "bad guys" have nothing to say that they want to hear.  Their goal is victory, often enough at any price.  Us vs. Them.  That's all there is.

So far as I can see dualism, as a human ideology, is often the antithesis of the teachings and actions of Jesus.  In his acceptance of the poor, he violated one of the fundamental dualisms of his day, the distinction between the wealthy/righteous and the poor/sinful.  He took pity on and healed the sick—in a time when illness was understood to be a symptom of God's displeasure.  He touched lepers.  He called a "sinful" tax collector to be one of his inner circle of disciples.  He had a very different attitude about another one of the basic dualisms of his day, the distinction between ("superior") men and ("inferior") women.  He even let women sit as his feet, a place normally reserved for male student/disciples.

Now, we take the point in these passages: there are wolves among the Jesus Movement sheep, advocating untenable moralities and theologies.  False prophets were making Jesus out to be someone he wasn't.  But we can't help but wonder who the compiler/author thought fell on the negative side of these dualities.  Who were the bad guys who took the easy way out and built their houses on sand?  Baptists, maybe.  Catholics?  Buddhists?  LGBTQ'ers?  Democrats?

My beef with dualism is that, for one thing, it simply doesn't reflect our human reality which is much more complex and where everything falls along continuums rather than at the two polar opposites.  For another thing, it leads to prejudice, arrogance, a contentious spirit, judgmentalism, meanness, bigotry, and a whole lot of violence.  The ultimate symbol of dualism is the Klan hanging black males for crimes they did not commit.  It is the horrific ideologies that led to World War II.

Dualism was a fundamental, unquestioned, supposedly common sense ideology of the ancient world. It is hardly surprising that we find it in the Bible.  That doesn't mean we have to buy into it.  So far as I can see, at least, the Spirit of Christ transcended it.  Amen.

Thursday, August 24, 2017

Matthew 7:7-12 - The Way Forward

As we have been reading through Matthew, we've been imagining two historical contexts of the gospel.  The first is the one in which Jesus originally taught and the second is the one of the early church in the decades after him.  The compiler/author of the gospel sought to connect the two, telling the story of Jesus to new followers who did not know him personally or know someone who had known him personally.  Matthew is thus a compilation of stories and teachings from and about Jesus that the author believed to be relevant to the churches.  Both contexts, Jesus' and the churches', were in play.

What did the author think that the churches need to hear?  What did Jesus have to offer the people of the Roman Empire in the first century?  According to the sermon on the mount, they needed a vision.  They had to be instructed that Jesus' way is not easy.  They needed to be warned about injurious behaviors that cripple lives.  They particularly needed to be warned about false pieties that only make matters worse.

And this brings us to Matthew 7:7-12 and the crux of the matter.  Jesus taught that the way forward was to trust God and then do for others what we would have them do for us.  That's it.

It may help us to comprehend the power of this passage and of the whole sermon if we imagine a small-ish chamber with a band of a dozen or fifteen first-century followers of Jesus in a city of the Roman Empire, probably in the eastern Mediterranean, listening intently to a reading of the gospel.  They were poor and the worries of life burdened them every day.  They coped as best they could.  What attracted them to Jesus of Nazareth was that his teachings provided them with a better way to cope, a way of living that was something more than a hand to mouth existence.  Trust God.  Do a better job of treating others with the respect and attention that you want from them.  You don't need tons of cash.  You don't have to go through useless rituals.  You don't have to be educated.  Jesus, speaking to them through the gospel, gave them a clear path to walk, one they could place their confidence in; one that, when they thought about it, made a lot of sense—and actually worked.  There was more to it than that, but not much.  Stay tuned.

Monday, August 21, 2017

Matthew 6 - Grasping & Striving

In our last last post, on Matthew 6:1-7:7, I claimed that the point of the passage is that the fundamental issue we humans face, according to Jesus, is grasping after things such as honor  and wealth— in other words, self-aggrandizement.  Looked at from a 21st-century context, I think that is one reasonable summation of Jesus' first century message.  But there is an obvious problem that we shouldn't walk past, which is the fine line between grasping after things and striving after them.

If greedy, self-serving grasping after what we want is one crucial element in human nature, so too is striving after what we want.  When we grasp and grab, we are at our worst.  When we strive and struggle, we are at our best.  When we strive for something, we have set a goal for ourselves to better ourselves or our situation.  Working for a new home or striving to serve our community, these are good things.  We grow, improve, and make a contribution to our society by striving after that which is better than what we have now, where we are now.  Progress is built on striving.

The problem is that there is a gray area between grasping and striving where striving morphs into grasping.  The desire to improve morphs into the darker desire to get what we think we deserve, at any cost.  Striving involves an investment in our self, our ego.  But Lord help us when self and ego are involved because they so easily take over and corrupt even our best intentions turning them into self-aggrandizement.  We end up corrupting the very things we strive after.

Sadly, religion is at least as much a victim of this tension between striving and grasping as any other aspect of life.  That is the point of Jesus' teachings about giving, praying, and fasting in secret (Matthew 6:1-18).  It is good to give, pray, and fast—until it isn't because our goal in doing these things has been corrupted with grasping self-concerns.  When we invest our self in something, that self wants something back for itself.  Invest our self in our nearest Presbyterian church and soon enough our good 'ole self wants to be an elder and sit on the session.  It resists changes the pastor wants to make 'cause it likes things the way they are.  It gets caught up in gossip, petty behaviors, and a fearful protection of the institution of the church. It is after all "my" church.

I don't see any easy cure that keeps our greedy, grasping self in check as we strive to do good things for ourselves, our families, and our communities (including our church).  Humility is hard, and even it can be corrupted by an aw-shucks false humility.  The Buddhist idea of non-self, unfortunately, faces the same problem of the self worming its way underneath non-self corrupting one's best efforts to be selfless.  We have to strive.  We are in so many ways defined by what we strive for.  Yet, what we strive for can end up consuming us and an oily, grasping pollution seeps into the very ground water of our striving.

Jesus said this stuff isn't easy.  Stay tuned.

Sunday, August 20, 2017

Matthew 6:1-7:6 - On Grasping

Another way of looking at Matthew 6 is to see it as ultimately being addressed to the early churches, the members of what I've been calling the "Jesus Movement."  It presents a charter for life in the new society they were creating in the first century, which was based on the teachings of Jesus.  Summarized most simply, Jesus taught to cease grasping after things.  Stop grasping after public recognition. Stop showing off your piety.  Stop grasping after wealth.  And in the opening verses of Matthew 7, he taught to stop grasping after self-affirmation by tearing down others.  Stop, in sum, building yourself up so you can feel important and "get ahead" of everyone else.  Jesus' words about God and possessions (6:24-34) sum up the matter: don't stress out over having material goods and enough food.  Stop grasping and grabbing for self-advancement.

In the last posting, I suggested that Matthew 6 could be seen as a dig at the wealthy of Jesus' day who did invest themselves in grasping after just these things.  Jesus himself may indeed have been speaking to the Pharisees and Sadducees, at least in part; but the author/compiler of Matthew would surely have seen that these teachings were crucial to building faithful, loving Christian communities in the early decades of the Jesus' Movement.  Grasping, greedy individuals disrupt their communities; they are a pain to people around them.  They represent what is most reprehensible in human society, and people resent them for their greedy need for attention and the way they treat people around them.

That is why the author concluded with words from Jesus that warned early Christians to stop judging others including each other.  Stop your greedy, grasping self-aggrandizement by tearing down others.  Get rid of the log in your own eye and then help others remove the specks in their eyes.  To summarise this whole point about grasping, the author then quoted Jesus' teaching that we shouldn't give what is holy to dogs or throw our valuables into a pigsty. That is exactly what we do when we "Grab for all the gusto you can get," as the old beer commercial put it.  Grasping behaviors come back to bite the greedy—and those around them.  They had no place in the new society of the early church.  There was a better way of doing things, and it was to that better way that the compiler/author next turned.  Stay tuned.

Saturday, August 19, 2017

Matthew 6

One way to read the Gospel of Matthew is to imagine its audience, which would have largely been the urban poor of the first century Roman Empire.  Another way is to imagine Jesus' audience, which would have been first century Jews in Judea and Galilee.  Most of them were poor, too, but not all of them; and  Jesus' teachings recorded in Matthew 6 clearly weren't addressed to poor people who wouldn't have had money to give to the poor (themselves!) whether openly or secretly.  They wouldn't have been inclined to show off their piety since it was a basic tenet of the day that poverty was a sign of God's displeasure.  They wouldn't have fasted, worried about storing up their riches, or had enough worldly goods to be slaves to them.  This is not to say that the poor couldn't have learned a thing or two from the teachings collected in this chapter.  The theme here is that the best way, the godly way to live is humbly.  They were already humbled by their low station in society, so they could have heard these words as an affirmation of their own place in the world.  In a sense, Jesus seems to have been saying that the wealthy do best when they behave as if they are poor instead of showing off their wealth and piety.  Poor Christians could have taken a measure of comfort and gained a measure of confidence from hearing these teachings in the gospel.

If we think about Jesus' teaching crowds of people in his day, on the other hand, the gospels do make it clear that wealthy folks did stop by to listen to him teach.  As time went by, they did more than just listen.  They confronted him, tested him, and tried to trick Jesus into making dangerous statements.  We can thus imagine some Pharisees or Sadducees standing at the fringes of the crowd, listening in to these words of Jesus; and we can imagine Jesus taking the opportunity of their presence to try to reach them with a different way of thinking about their wealth.  His central point was that no one can serve two masters.  If these wealthy folks used their wealth to puff themselves up and to thus serve their own ends, then they became slaves to that wealth.

We've heard this tidbit of Jesus' wisdom so often, we take it for granted:  where our attention is, where our concerns are, the things we lose sleep over—these things own us, enslave us, and separate us from the Spirit.  In the first century, it would have made no sense to the wealthy to include wealth among those things that own us.  The very notion would have been startling and even scandalous to the Pharisees and Sadducees.  God had given them their wealth as a sign of divine approval, so how could that wealth enslave them and drive them apart from God?  Nonsense!  Illogical!  And dangerous.

It's no wonder they finally had him crucified.

Thursday, August 17, 2017

Matthew 5:43-48 - Love Even Bigots

In biblical times, there was no divide between religion and politics, faith and the state.  When Jesus taught, he taught in a political context and his teachings had political ramifications.  When he told his audiences to love their enemies and pray for their persecutors, he was talking about the Romans and the Jewish establishment as much as he was about the neighborhood bully.  In our time and context, we can understand Jesus' teaching concerning loving enemies as advocating an alternative political and personal practice aimed at the peaceful transformation of human life.  Love is thus made holy.  It is not just about sex.  It is not just about family feelings.  It is a manifestation of the Spirit working in our lives to help us to walk toward the Kingdom, which Jesus assured us is just around the corner.  It is peace.  It is dharma (ธรรมะ).

The recent events in Charlottesville, Virginia, and the profound, devastating shame Donald Trump has brought on the American presidency by his immoral attempts to place neo-nazis & klansmen on the same level as civil rights protestors throws into sharp relief the fact that faith today is still about politics.  It must be about politics.  And it is still about transformation.  In the 1950s and 1960s, we witnessed the power of the peaceable confrontation of persecution through non-violent resistance.  That resistance, painful as it was, took the United States further down the road toward the Kingdom, if only a little ways.  That was then.  Now, the work has to be done again.  Trump threatens to return us to the 1940s, to give powerful voice to racist bigotry through a shameful play at equivalency between the klan and the civil rights protest movement.  (In late breaking news, A Reuter's report quotes Mike Pence as saying, "I stand with the president and I stand by those words," meaning Trump's take on Charlottesville.  There is no escaping the moment; it is not just about Trump.)  Given the outrage Trump (and now Pence) has sparked, we can hope that the United States, as a whole, does not want to go back to the bad old days of Jim Crow.  But will it discover a new generation of Rosa Parks and Martin Luther Kings to carry it forward in pursuit of social justice and equality—in pursuit of the Kingdom?  It looks like we're going to find out sooner rather than later.

In the meantime, the disciples' memories of Jesus' teachings, as recorded in the gospel, remain powerful and pertinent to our turbulent times.  Thank God for their memories.  Thank God our ancestors in the faith had the inspired presence of mind to get them written down.  Amen